Browse categories
Explore
Fiverr Pro
English
$
USD
I will beta read and critique your short story with no ai
Gig Summary
Professional editor with a master's degree in creative writing
Hi there! I'm Brian! In addition to years of experience writing and publishing my own essays, book reviews, and poems, I've worked in academia and e-commerce on magazines, e-books, web content, and so...
Level 2
Has met high performance criteria and has a proven track record for meeting client expectations.
What people loved about this freelancer
davidtklein
United States
This is my first time needing a beta reader, and my first time on Fiverr. I didn't know what to expect. Brian gave me great feedback, and delivered it quickly....
janycampana
United States
Brian knows his stuff! He gave excellent advice and feedback. My writing benefitted greatly from his coaching. If you need an editor, Brian is easy to work with and a very detailed communicator.
nakasa
United States
Brian provided very useful critique so I could polish my work and improve my writing skills overall as I’m not a very experienced writer! Great service, thank you so much!
claireszewcz586
United States
Brian did an excellent job beta reading the first 5,000 words of my novel. I glanced over his profile and thought he'd make a good fit for reviewing it (it...
ajdesantis29
United States
Brian left a very detailed review which was incredibly helpful for one of my MFA portfolio pieces. He seems to know what he’s doing.
About this Gig
Hello writers! I can't wait to beta read your creative writing. Whether it's flash fiction or a longer short story, I'm here to help!
My Qualifications
- Master's degree in creative writing
- Over a dozen publications in literary magazines
- More than five years of professional writing and editing experience
My Gig
As an experienced beta reader and editor, I'm committed to helping you get your short story publication-ready. I provide thorough feedback, suggestions, and developmental edits on just about everything a fiction writer might need, such as tone, character development, plot, theme, imagery, word choice, pacing, and more. I also do sample line edits to help you assess the quality of your prose.
I strive to respect your artistic talent and intent. My goal isn't to drastically change your story but to help it shine through clearly and powerfully.
PLEASE NOTE: I do not read stories that contain graphic or adult content or that discriminate against anyone. Keep it kind. Keep it PG-13 or under.
If you want to make sure I'm the right editor for you, please take a look at my FAQ section and let me know if you have any questions.
I look forward to reading your lovely words!
Language:
English
Delivery style preference
Please inform the freelancer of any preferences or concerns regarding the use of AI tools in the completion and/or delivery of your order.
My Portfolio
FAQ
Do you edit sci-fi and fantasy?
Yes! I have edited multiple books and stories in these genres, as well as light horror, literary/realistic fiction, and more! As my description states, I do not review any work that contains highly graphic content.
Who are your favorite writers?
Poets: Aimee Nezhukumatathil, Ted Kooser, Naomi Shihab Nye, Mary Oliver Essayists: Brian Doyle, Brenda Miller, Annie Dillard Novelists: Anthony Doerr, Marilynne Robinson
Do you critique experimental short stories?
I critique both traditional and experimental works of fiction, but I'm probably not a good fit for extreme avant-garde stuff. I prefer work that immediately grounds me in a narrative and/or images without being unnecessarily opaque.
Reviews
77 reviews for this Gig
| (72) | ||
| (4) | ||
| (1) | ||
| (0) | ||
| (0) |
Rating Breakdown
- Seller communication level
- Quality of delivery
- Value of delivery
Sort By
Most relevant
D davidtklein
United States
This is my first time needing a beta reader, and my first time on Fiverr. I didn't know what to expect. Brian gave me great feedback, and delivered it quickly. The guidance he provided looks really good, and I plan to incorporate most of it.
$50
Price
2 days
Duration
B 
Seller's Response
Helpful?C cokagbue
United States
This was my first time working with Brian. He completed the review quickly and delivered it two days ahead of schedule. I appreciate his feedback and will take his suggestions into consideration as I make the necessary corrections.
$50-$100
Price
5 days
Duration
B Seller's Response
Helpful?W willblackwoo519
Czech Republic
quick replies, sharp eye for detail, excellent work
$50
Price
6 days
Duration
B Seller's Response
Helpful?A ambiguousguy21
United States
Excellent analysis of the story.
$50
Price
4 days
Duration
B Seller's Response
Helpful?J janycampana
United States
Ongoing collaborationDon't hesitate to have Brian edit your work. He excels at helping your craft reach the highest level.
$50
Price
8 days
Duration
B Seller's Response
Helpful?
Reviews
77 reviews for this Gig
| (72) | ||
| (4) | ||
| (1) | ||
| (0) | ||
| (0) |
Rating Breakdown
- Seller communication level
- Quality of delivery
- Value of delivery
Sort By
Most relevant
D davidtklein
United States
This is my first time needing a beta reader, and my first time on Fiverr. I didn't know what to expect. Brian gave me great feedback, and delivered it quickly. The guidance he provided looks really good, and I plan to incorporate most of it.
$50
Price
2 days
Duration
B Seller's Response
Helpful?C cokagbue
United States
This was my first time working with Brian. He completed the review quickly and delivered it two days ahead of schedule. I appreciate his feedback and will take his suggestions into consideration as I make the necessary corrections.
$50-$100
Price
5 days
Duration
B Seller's Response
Helpful?W willblackwoo519
Czech Republic
quick replies, sharp eye for detail, excellent work
$50
Price
6 days
Duration
B Seller's Response
Helpful?A ambiguousguy21
United States
Excellent analysis of the story.
$50
Price
4 days
Duration
B Seller's Response
Helpful?J janycampana
United States
Ongoing collaborationDon't hesitate to have Brian edit your work. He excels at helping your craft reach the highest level.
$50
Price
8 days
Duration
B Seller's Response
Helpful?
