I will beta read critique manuscript, romance beta reader mystery thriller memoir novel

4.9
4.9

Nigeria

I speak English, Italian, Portuguese, German, Spanish, French, Dutch

14 orders completed

Gig Summary

Beta reader expert

I am Samuel Moore, a professional beta reader, developmental editor, book editor, and book formatter. I always made reading and writing my hobby since I was 18; now I make it a passion and part of my ...
About this Gig

Find out how your story truly lands with a reader before you query or publish.


Whether you're polishing a twisty romance, mystery & thriller, memoir, manuscript, I offer honest, constructive feedback built around what makes each of those genres workwhether that's slow-burn chemistry, clues and twists, dread and atmosphere, or high-stakes tension.


What I Look For:


  • Plot & Pacing: Plot holes, dragging scenes, rushed twists, and story momentum.
  • Characters & Dialogue: Motivations, character arcs, relationship dynamics, and natural dialogue.
  • Reader Experience: Where I felt hooked, where my attention dipped, and how the emotional payoff hit.


What You Get:


  • Chapter-by-Chapter Feedback: Notes tracking my reactions chapter by chapter.
  • Final Beta Report: A clear summary of strengths, weak spots, and practical suggestions to strengthen your draft.


Your creative voice stays yours. I never rewrite your prose, and I'm happy to sign an NDA upon request.


Not sure which tier fits?

Message me with your genre and word count before ordering!

Genre:

Horror/ thriller

•

Memoir/ biography

•

Mystery

•

Romance

•

Fantasy

Language:

English

Delivery style preference

Please inform the freelancer of any preferences or concerns regarding the use of AI tools in the completion and/or delivery of your order.

My Portfolio

Reviews

9 reviews for this Gig
4.9

(8)
(1)
(0)
(0)
(0)
Rating Breakdown
  • Seller communication level
    4.9
  • Quality of delivery
    4.9
  • Value of delivery
    4.8
Sort By
Most relevant
  • S

    solomon_drowne

    US

    United States

    Ongoing collaboration
    4.7

    swift review, corrected an issue with the scope reference quickly and with proficiency.

    $50

    Price

    6 days

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
  • A

    aura_olympian

    US

    United States

    5

    This review was well-written, eloquent, and easy-to-understand. His feedback is neither ego massage nor negativity. It's a balanced, respectful, constructive review that makes it easier for me as a writer to identify things I've potentially overlooked. It also provides me with insights into reader perspectives,...

    $50

    Price

    3 days

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
  • S

    solomon_drowne

    US

    United States

    Ongoing collaboration
    5

    Chapter VI feedback delivered as discussed

    $50

    Price

    4 days

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
  • S

    solomon_drowne

    US

    United States

    Ongoing collaboration
    5

    As advertised and thusly delivered. Feedback on a work of this complexity and depth is crucial to developing the program from a personal ambition to something that may have public-facing impact. Consistently engaging with the providing manuscript and providing continuous feedback is helpful in iterating the necessary revisions.

    $50

    Price

    5 days

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
  • S

    solomon_drowne

    US

    United States

    Ongoing collaboration
    5

    Valuable feedback for complicated manuscript.

    $50

    Price

    5 days

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
Reviews

9 reviews for this Gig
4.9

(8)
(1)
(0)
(0)
(0)
Rating Breakdown
  • Seller communication level
    4.9
  • Quality of delivery
    4.9
  • Value of delivery
    4.8
Sort By
Most relevant
  • S

    solomon_drowne

    US

    United States

    Ongoing collaboration
    4.7

    swift review, corrected an issue with the scope reference quickly and with proficiency.

    $50

    Price

    6 days

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
  • A

    aura_olympian

    US

    United States

    5

    This review was well-written, eloquent, and easy-to-understand. His feedback is neither ego massage nor negativity. It's a balanced, respectful, constructive review that makes it easier for me as a writer to identify things I've potentially overlooked. It also provides me with insights into reader perspectives,...

    $50

    Price

    3 days

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
  • S

    solomon_drowne

    US

    United States

    Ongoing collaboration
    5

    Chapter VI feedback delivered as discussed

    $50

    Price

    4 days

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
  • S

    solomon_drowne

    US

    United States

    Ongoing collaboration
    5

    As advertised and thusly delivered. Feedback on a work of this complexity and depth is crucial to developing the program from a personal ambition to something that may have public-facing impact. Consistently engaging with the providing manuscript and providing continuous feedback is helpful in iterating the necessary revisions.

    $50

    Price

    5 days

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No
  • S

    solomon_drowne

    US

    United States

    Ongoing collaboration
    5

    Valuable feedback for complicated manuscript.

    $50

    Price

    5 days

    Duration

    Helpful?
    Yes
    No